Durnford & Ors v. (1) One Touch Solution Limited (in CVL) and (2) Hiscox Insurance Company Limited [2026] EWHC 2559 (BP)
Simon Johnson and Mairi Innes, instructed by HFW LLP, acted for the successful claimants in a significant and wide-ranging liability trial arising from the collapse of developments by The Care Home Group (Carlauren). In a judgment running to over 400 pages, Recorder Bignell KC, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, held that the vast majority of the claimants had established liability against One Touch.
The judgment addresses several important issues of wider significance, including:
- the existence and scope of duties of care in tort owed by estate agents and property intermediaries to purchasers of off-plan property;
- the circumstances in which online terms and conditions will bind consumers and other purchasers;
- findings that terms purportedly excluding or limiting the duties assumed by the estate agent were ineffective, inter alia by operation of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and, in relation to a Swiss corporate purchaser, the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977;
- the consideration of whether a determination by a non-statutory ombudsman, namely The Property Ombudsman, can give rise to a res judicata preventing later court proceedings by parity of reasoning with Clark v. In Focus Asset Management [2014] EWCA Civ 118;
- the consideration of duty nexus issues; the judgment provides a multi-faceted contrast with the recent decision in Niprose Investments Limited v. Vincents Solicitors Limited [2026] EWHC 2320 (Ch);
- the time when causes of action arise for the purposes of limitation in failed property investment cases, including discussion of the Nykredit line of authorities.
The Court found that One Touch had assumed duties of care to the claimants, notwithstanding its attempt at characterising its activities as those of a mere marketing agent for Carlauren, and that it had breached those duties in numerous respects when promoting and recommending the purchase proposition. The Court further dismissed the defendants’ limitation defence, finding that the cause of action accrued on exchange of contracts, not the earlier time of reservation. The court extended time for a small number of claimants under section 14A of the Limitation Act 1980.
Matters in relation to quantum and coverage were subject to a separate trial; judgment is awaited.